That's the question I found myself asking after coming across an article entitled Computer glitch hid some CPS records for years, may have led to wrongful removals of children from families . Here are the first few paragraphs:
A computer glitch at Arizona's child-welfare agency kept some public records hidden from parents and their lawyers for more than 15 years.
The missing records could have led to children being improperly removed from their homes and stopped caregivers from filing civil claims against the state.
Arizona Department of Economic Security officials were notifying the state's 15 presiding Juvenile Court judges of the glitch on Friday. They also were sending notices to more than 30,000 people who received incomplete public records in the past two years but the state is unable to track or notify those who requested and received incomplete records before 2010.
How long has that bug been in there?
... the database system that tracks CPS cases, called CHILDS, had been programmed to print about one-third of the information considered public record under state and federal law. The programming error had been in place since the database was created in 1996.
So over the past 2.5 years, 30000 people were effected, but the system has been around since 1996 - 16 years. Assuming that there were roughly as many cases per year in Arizona that'd mean that close to 200,000 people might have been affected. Of course the actual number of kids abducted is likely to be a lot lower.
Compare though to "stereotypical kidnappings" - crimes which "involve someone the child does not know or a slight acquaintance who holds the child overnight, transports the child 50 miles or more, kills the child, demands ransom, or intends to keep the child permanently." There are an estimated 151 such cases/year across the US. To beat the 151 abductions/year nationally just in the state of Arizona you'd need to have only had about 1% of child removal orders overturned by the additional documentation this bug prevented from being released, a figure that doesn't seem implausible.
HT: Fathers and Families