What are the effects of education promoting high self-esteem?

Nor does high self-esteem protect against teen pregnancy, juvenile delinquency, alcoholism, drug abuse, or chronic welfare dependency. Several comprehensive reviews of the research literature by different authors have all concluded that self-esteem doesn't cause much of anything. Even the book sponsored by the California Task Force to Promote Self-Esteem and Personal and Social Responsibility, which spent a quarter of a million dollars trying to raise Californians' self-esteeem, found that self-esteem isn't linked to academic achievement, good behaviour, or any other outcome the Task Force was formed to address.

... Roy Baumeister, the lead author of an extensive review of the research on self-esteem, found that self-esteem does not lead to better grades, improved work performance, decreased violence, or less cheating. In fact, people with high self esteem are often more violent and more likely to cheat. "It is very questionable whether [the few benefits] justify the effort and expense that schools, parents and therapists have put into raising self-esteem," Baumeister wrote. "After all these years, I'm sorry to say, my reccomendation is this: forget about self-esteem and concentrate more on self-control and self-discipline."

- Jean Twenge, Generation Me, p. 65/66

Random links

THE MINIMALIST; Frosty the Vegetable
Per Harold McGee, author of On Food and Cooking: "The quality of vegetables is more or less preserved at the stage they're frozen. If frozen vegetables are handled expeditiously, they are often better than buying 'fresh' at the store."
Let's wipe out toilet paper
"Using tissue after you've been to the loo is bad for the planet. Washing is the greener option – and it's more hygienic too." - I can't say that I buy the argument that it's greener (takes energy to process, transport, and heat water for cleaning) but I do buy the more hygenic argument.
Gun Control Wouldn't Have Stopped Loughner: And Loughner shouldn't start a new push for gun control
Hmn... "Despite constantly expanding gun ownership—the number of new firearms entering American possession averages around 4 million a year—and expanded rights to legally carry weapons, the last two decades have seen a 41 percent decline in violent crime rates. Since the 2004 expiration of the 'assault weapon' ban, murder rates are down 15 percent."
Once Upon a Time in Afghanistan...
Afghanistan before the Taliban in photo-essay form: "Record stores, Mad Men furniture, and pencil skirts -- when Kabul had rock 'n' roll, not rockets." Seems that Afghanistan isn't necessarily where empires go to die, as some have been claimed.

Demographic Winter

An interesting documentary on the subject of population aging. It's about an hour long. Also comes with some annoying Spanish(?) subtitles.

Random links

A beef with Taco Bell: When is meat not really meat?
Apparently Taco Bell's "seasoned ground beef" only contains 36% beef - someone's starting a class-action lawsuit in protest. Here I'm guessing that the lawyers will be the primary winners - although a name change for Taco Bell's "beef" might be in order.
Thought for Food: Imagining Food Consumption Reduces Actual Consumption
"A new study by researchers at Carnegie Mellon University, published in Science, shows that when you imagine eating a certain food, it reduces your actual consumption of that food. This landmark discovery changes the decades-old assumption that thinking about something desirable increases cravings for it and its consumption."
Why You Need to Be Critical in Order to Be Teachable
A quote from "How to read a book"; learning is an active process.
Why 3D doesn't work and never will. Case closed.
I saw a bunch of 3D imax stuff growing up, but haven't been to see any of the more Hollywood-style films in 3D. Suspect that I probably won't either - I seem to recall the 3D stuff being kinda headache-inducing as this piece notes.

Pages

Subscribe to Rotundus.com RSS