Does self-help and self-esteem make people feel happy?

The BBC doesn't think so. See their article entitled Self-help makes you feel worse. Ditto this speaker at TED:

... One problem that psychology has had is instead of looking at this intersubjectivity, or the importance of the social brain, to humans who come into the world helpless and need each other tremendously, is that they focus instead on the self. and self-esteem, and not self other, is sort of "me," not "we." And I think this has been a really tremendous problem. It goes against our biology and nature. It hasn't made us any happier at all.

Because when you think about it, people are happiest when in flow, when they're absorbed in something out in the world, when they're with other people, when they're active, engaged in sports, focusing on a loved one, learning, having sex, whatever. They're not sitting in front of the mirror trying to figure themselves out, or thinking about themselves. These are not the periods when you feel happiest. And I think the self-esteem movement has made it more difficult for people to be happy.

The other thing is, that a piece of evidence is, is if you look at computerized text analysis of people who commit suicide, what you find there, and it's quite interesting, is use of the first person singular, "I, me, mine," not "we" and "us." And the letters are less hopeless than they are really alone. And being alone is very unnatural to the human. There is a profound need to belong. So self-focused attention brings mood down.

- Excerpted from TED.com: Nancy Etcoff on the surprising science of happiness

Would you like to see charitable tax credits increased?

[T]he great majority of Canadians donated very little or nothing throughout the year. A small fraction of the population, ten percent, is responsible for contributing the lion’s share, nearly two-thirds, of all charitable donations. Within the group of those who chose to make one or more charitable donations during 2007, half of the donors contributed less than $120 in annual giving. For individuals with incomes over $100,000, the median amount donated over twelve months was $210.

- Excerpted from a CARDUS letter to Parliament

I'm a little shocked that the amounts donated are so low. There's a campaign going on to increase the Canadian Federal Charitable Tax Credit from 29% - 42% - more details available here - that aims to increase this.

Personally I think that it's a bad idea to increase these tax credits, and I'd actually like to see them scrapped entirely. I'm not a big fan of the government spending other people's money for those causes you may support and your money for causes that you may not support.

Should a Christian be forced to fund their local mosque? Should a Muslim be forced to fund Sikh temples? Should an atheist be forced to fund a Christian church? It might make it easier for some worthwhile causes to get donations coming in, but it would also increase the funding to some undesirable causes - e.g. the Canadian Federation for Sexual Health (what Planned Parenthood renamed its Canadian division to a few years back).

The CARDUS letter notes that ten percent of the population is responsible to contributing 2/3 of all charitable donations. Is it that much different than the proportion of taxes paid by the richest 10% of the population - they pay a majority of Canadian federal taxes.

HT: Arnold

J.I. Packer on the internet

I'm amazed at the amount of time people spend on the internet. I'm not against technology, but all tools should be used to their best advantage. We should be spending our time on things that have staying power, instead of on the latest thought of the latest blogger—and then moving on quickly to the next blogger. That makes us more superficial, not more thoughtful.

- J.I. Packer in WORLD Magazine

*insert comment here about this being an ironic thing to post on a blog*

Thinking

Bishop J. C. Ryle once said, "The cause of true religion has gained a great step in a parish, or congregation, or family, when people begin to think. Thoughtlessness about spiritual things is one great feature of the unconverted. It cannot be said, in many cases, that they like the Gospel or dislike it; for they do not give it a place in their thoughts."

C.S. Lewis said, "God has room for people with very little sense. But he expects them to use all the sense they have." He added, "God is no fonder of intellectual slackers than of any other slackers." And John R. W. Stott said, "We not only need to think about Christian things, we need to think Christianly about things."

One with even greater authority than these said, "Thou shalt love the Lord your God with all your heart, all your soul, and all your mind."

- Donald T. Williams
Excerpted from: Touchstone Magazine, April 2009

Pages

Subscribe to Rotundus.com RSS